RPA vs IDP: Which One Should You Choose in 2024?

Whether it’s the straightforward efficiency of RPA or the advanced capabilities of IDP, understanding these technologies is key to unlocking new levels of productivity and accuracy in your business processes.
September 18, 2024
RPA vs IDP: Which One Should You Choose in 2024?

Looking for a way to streamline your business processes but not sure whether to go with RPA or IDP? Whether it’s the straightforward efficiency of RPA or the advanced capabilities of IDP, understanding these technologies is key to unlocking new levels of productivity and accuracy in your business processes.

But what exactly are these technologies, how do they differ, and which one is right for your business? Let’s dive right in.

What is Robotic process automation (RPA)?

Robotic process automation (RPA) is a technology that uses software robots or "bots" to automate repetitive and rule-based tasks typically performed by humans. These bots can handle tasks such as data entry, processing transactions, generating reports, and managing routine communication. A study shows that the businesses receive a typical return of USD 6.74 for every USD 1 invested in RPA technology.

4 Key benefits of robotic process automation

1. Save time by automating repetitive tasks: RPA automates routine tasks which frees up human employees for more valuable work.

2. Reduce costs by eliminating manual labor: RPA reduces the need for manual work which leads to cost savings for the organization.

3. Improve accuracy by eliminating human error: RPA can operate continuously without errors, improving efficiency and allowing human employees to focus on more strategic, creative, or complex work.

4. Scale operations easily by handling more workloads: RPA manages increased workloads without requiring additional staff which makes scaling operations easier.

But how exactly does RPA work?

RPA is designed to mimic human actions on a computer. Think about how you copy data from one place and paste it into another—RPA can do that, only faster and without mistakes. And it’s not just about speed; it’s also about consistency. These bots follow the same steps every time, ensuring that the process is done exactly as it should be, every single time.

So, what’s the catch? Well, RPA isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. It’s most effective for tasks that are rule-based and structured, where the process remains consistent and doesn’t vary much from day to day.

Intelligent document processing (IDP): What is it?

Intelligent document processing (IDP) takes data extraction to the next level by combining AI, machine learning, and natural language processing to understand and process complex documents. Unlike traditional methods that rely on manual data entry or basic automation, IDP can read, interpret, and extract information from unstructured data like emails, invoices, contracts, and even handwritten notes.

Imagine analyzing hundreds of invoices to find specific information—IDP automates this by recognizing patterns, context, and the structure of the content. It doesn't just pull out data blindly; it understands the context, making the data it extracts more accurate and reliable. 

5 key benefits of intelligent document processing:

  1. Enhanced accuracy: Reduces errors by automatically extracting and processing data with AI-driven precision.
  2. Increased efficiency: Speeds up document processing, saving time on manual data entry and review.
  3. Scalability: Easily handles large volumes of documents, adapting to business growth without a significant increase in resources.
  4. Improved compliance: Ensures data processing adheres to regulatory standards, reducing the risk of compliance issues.
  5. Cost savings: Lowers operational costs by automating repetitive tasks, allowing staff to focus on higher-value activities.


IDP systems continuously learn from each document they process, improving their accuracy over time. This means they’re not just getting the job done; they’re getting better at it as they go. Whether it's extracting names, dates, or financial figures, IDP can handle a variety of tasks with precision.

IDP has a wide range of practical uses across different sectors. In finance, it automates tasks like invoice processing and loan applications, saving time and reducing errors. Legal firms rely on it to organize contracts and maintain compliance, streamlining case management. Additionally, in supply chain management, IDP processes documents like shipping records and purchase orders, improving efficiency and minimizing manual labor.

RPA vs. IDP: What’s the Difference?

RPA automates repetitive and rule-based tasks across systems, while IDP focuses on extracting and interpreting data from unstructured and semi-structured documents using AI. While both are incredible tools, they serve different purposes.

Let’s understand the differences in detail:

Aspects

RPA (Robotic Process Automation)

IDP (Intelligent Document Processing)

Definition

RPA automates repetitive, rule-based tasks by mimicking human interactions with digital systems.

IDP automates the extraction, interpretation, and processing of data from unstructured and semi-structured documents.

Primary Function

Executes predefined processes by interacting with software applications.

Extracts and interprets data from various document types, often using AI and ML techniques.

Data Type

Structured data (e.g., databases, spreadsheets)

Unstructured and semi-structured data (e.g., invoices, contracts, emails)

Technology Used

Basic automation tools, often rule-based.

Advanced AI/ML algorithms, natural language processing (NLP), optical character recognition (OCR).

Customization

Requires specific rules or scripts to be set up for each task.

Learns and adapts to new document types with training and AI models.

Complexity of Tasks

Best suited for simple, repetitive tasks.

Handles more complex tasks involving data interpretation and contextual understanding.

Error Handling

Follows strict rules, so it may fail when encountering unexpected scenarios.

Uses AI to adapt to and correct errors in data extraction and interpretation.

Learning Capability

Static; does not learn or improve over time.

Dynamic; improves accuracy over time with machine learning.

Integration

Integrates with existing systems via APIs and UI interactions.

Integrates with document management systems, ERP, CRM, and other enterprise software.

Industry Focus

Applicable across industries for back-office operations, IT, and customer service.

Widely used in finance, healthcare, legal, HR, and insurance industries for document-intensive processes.

When to use RPA vs. IDP?

Wondering when to pull the trigger on RPA or IDP? Here’s a quick tip:

  • Opt for RPA if you’re dealing with repetitive and predictable tasks that don’t require much thinking. Perfect for data entry or simple transactional processes. RPA is like having an extra pair of hands that never gets tired.

    Use cases: Data entry, invoice processing, employee onboarding, report generation, and inventory management. Why? Because these tasks are repetitive and follow predictable patterns, automating them boosts efficiency and accuracy.

  • Go withIDP if your tasks involve complex documents like contracts or invoices where the data isn’t always neatly organized. IDP outsmarts in scenarios where you need to understand context and extract specific information.

    Use cases: Analyzing contracts, processing medical records, screening resumes, reviewing legal documents, and analyzing financial statements because it can handle diverse and unstructured formats while understanding context and extracting relevant information.

RPA or IDP: Which one to choose?

Still on the fence? The answer might not be a straightforward one. When deciding between RPA and IDP, think about what you need to achieve.

If you’re facing repetitive tasks that follow a clear set of rules—like entering data into a system or processing standard transactions—RPA is your best bet. It automates these routine activities, freeing up your time for more strategic work.

On the other hand, if you need to handle data from documents that aren’t as straightforward—like invoices, contracts, or medical records—IDP is the ideal choice. IDP excels at extracting and interpreting data from unstructured or semi-structured documents, using advanced AI to make sense of varied formats and information. 

Bottom line?

RPA is great for automating those repetitive rule-based tasks that bog you down and making your processes more efficient and accurate. But when it comes to handling complex documents, IDP really takes the spotlight. It leverages AI to analyze unstructured data, pulling out and interpreting the information you need with impressive precision.

When deciding between RPA and IDP, it’s all about matching the right tool to your needs. By understanding these distinctions, you can select the technology that aligns best with your business goals, ensuring that your operations are streamlined and optimized.

All right. Decided IDP is the solution you’re looking for? Try Docxster for FREE! Start with our "Forever Free" plan and experience how Docxster ensures your documents are processed quickly and accurately. Try it today and see the difference for yourself!

RPA vs IDP FAQs

1. What is IDP vs RPA vs OCR?

IDP (Intelligent Document Processing) uses AI to extract and analyze data from unstructured documents, RPA (Robotic Process Automation) automates repetitive, rule-based tasks by mimicking human actions, and OCR (Optical Character Recognition) converts scanned or printed text into digital text for easier processing and analysis.

2. In which scenarios is IDP more effective than RPA?

IDP is more effective than RPA in scenarios involving unstructured or semi-structured data processing, particularly when dealing with varied document types. It excels in tasks requiring intelligent data extraction, interpretation, and analysis from complex sources like invoices, contracts, or handwritten forms.

3. How does IDP complement RPA in automation processes?

IDP enhances RPA by handling unstructured data from documents, emails, and images. It can extract relevant information from these sources, which RPA can then use to execute further automated processes.

4. What are the common use cases for IDP? 

Common use cases for Intelligent Document Processing (IDP) include automating the extraction of data from invoices, contracts, and forms, where the content and layout can vary significantly.

IDP is used to streamline processing by converting unstructured data into structured formats for easier management and analysis. It also enhances workflows in industries such as finance, legal, and healthcare, where handling large volumes of documents is crucial.

5. What’s Docxster’s “Free Forever” plan all about?

Docxster’s “Free Forever” plan lets you access all the core features at no cost for as long as you need. You can streamline your document processing tasks efficiently with no hidden fees or time limits. It’s all about giving you a chance to experience the benefits of Docxster’s technology without any financial commitment.